P Leutbtleisrhsers’ Letter
Oprah Backlash Unfair ties are done because we have
Thank you for your article on always lived and continue to
the O
Why Bprah
Is Heesch
r Snool
. Afc, “O
richpr
a Scm ah Bas
hool Uahin
ndrg:
erks and Rankings live in a society where race
matters, where one group, by
Fire?” ( DiversityInc.com - Jan. 3). It law, not just practice, was
was ve made to pay dire conse-Exact quences because of their race.
provid Vestiges of that same discrimi-
My onMry tasteful and respectful.
ly what I exopnesctterfrroemcently sent an e-mail newslet- do you ask? How are best practices determined?
ers of divetresritt yoiuntfionrgmitastinoenw. benchmarking serv- What’s the methodology behind the questions and
ly commeincte.th Wate’r yeoumhenavtieonn’ted, so we thought collection process? nation still exist against the
mentiownee’ddtiasktehtahtiisfothpp eogritrulsnwiteyreto offer our opinion. Our data is collected frosmamtehemminoorreittyhgarnou2p0s0-today.
white,Bwel oouwldisththeescchoonotel nbteftrooom Monster’s web site: question survey filled out bIyf c yoomu p da onnieost cboemlopnegtitnogthe
extravagant for them? Or if it was for the DiversityInc Top 50a.ff Techtiesdisgorouurpssevaenndthdoyenaort
Bill G“a Ttreasdwitihoonablluyi, ldt ivtheresi stcyhboeonlc, hmarks – such as the rank- conducting the competitionsh. aMreotrheethcuanltu6r0a0l, c eo comnpoam- ic
wouldintghseroef bmeasguaczhinehsoosupclah as Fortune, Diversity, Inc [sic] and social systems that existed
and Hispanic Business – have focused on locating those nies requested our survey and we estimate that well
over 300 will complete it. Paanrdticeixpisattiaosnais reusupltmoofrleaws
MichetlhleatDa.rCe osltla innsdouts so others can learn from them. than 100 percent from threpeay sseeadrsaaggaoin(stthyeosuecaonnddyour
WindsWohri ,leCothnens.e lists provide best practices of diversity ancestors because of your
leaders, they don’t necessarily provide a way for other year we’ve had that kind of increase).
According to its web sitera, cMe,oannsdtewr hisicwhocrrkeiantged barri-
companies to gauge their own practices. We need to be rewmiitnhdHedartrhiastInteractievres tfoordtehliavtergriotsub peonfch pemoaprlke,intgh.en
GLBT-“BWahsihleinagmineaPsurirnetmMenutsltikEen‘drepresentaisti soune’sisocf oimncmluosni-on inNtoeimthaenr yMonster noryoHuarcrains ’tisoar Tshoopu5ld0
ncootmcpoamnpy.lain
Youly supseeadkaasbaoduitverrasnittyinmge, trraicc, iistt shouldasnpoetctbseotfheouornlAy meriOcannlysoocnie etoyf the comapbaonuitesthoenetfhfoerirtsamdvaidsoertyopia nncleulde
radio mbleoawsuhraermdes.ntWahcaotmapbaonuyt urseegsu. -The M[hoanvsete]rbdeievnertshitey strugisglae Tfo op r
A5f0riccoanmpanyt.hMemoninstearnaynthdinHga . rris don’t even
lar newbesnpcahpmearsrkthwailtl a insk sisHtRomnapnraignetr-s to aAssmes esricthaenisr scionmce- theimr e anpt pieoanra“ndciv eeors nity” on
tIhweioruhldomasekpathgeast.the gentleman
ing nuptatnyi,erse’ leigffioorutss ianttaarcekas s osunchgaayss overatlhl ewsoerk Afmorc ee ricraenp- shores. WWiethnoeuedt utonderstaannddinogthwehrsatwahototph-ipnekrfloikrme hinimg not
and lersebsieanntsa?tiNonewansdpadpiveerrsslitiykeinthseenior lebveelrsemofinmdaendagthe-at AfcroicmanpaAnmy earcitcuaanlsly dobees,gritu’sdigme pthoessribecleogtoniutinodne, rtshtaenidnclu-
Daily mFreenetm. HaonwienveKr,iningsatdodnit,ioNn. Yto., this mwan eraegethmeenfitr-slet vbeelnefichioarwierseolafti levgeanlloyn-parstiiocnip, aenttcs.,coafntdheotseermwhinoewwehra etand are
no lonqgueerstpiounbnlaisirhe,ltehteteMrsona s ctceursbinegnchmarskuwpipllogroteadnraadcdisim- , diastctrriimbuinteastioofndiversitystmillavniacgtiemmseonft rtaoce ismmualantde.discrimi-
blackstioofnablesintegp laaznyd oarskofemJepwlosyceoens -and ajonbd sie neekqeuraslihtyowof every Wsoertaalsfofed cto-n’t see nthateiovnalutheaitnthmeelaasrugreirngsoecmietpylocyr-eated
trollintghetyhepemrceediviea,ancoormdpa ontyh’sedyivpeurstity eifnfogrtesv.”ery aspect of theeeiprelrivce esp,tiforonms withoauntdthpeercpoenttreaxtt edo.f Yceosr,pwoeranteeed every-
up letters Wweadrnisianggree o.f Rman iskcienggesnaar-en’t bensclham vearryktso—slave codea s,cctoomJipmlisChrmowen, t. Thoenpeerocfeapltliorancsesoftoemmpolvoeyeteoswaatrd a
tion. Bthuety’
trheeryantkhiinngks.iOt’sufrinar etitcoles, Webinta orsseegrrieesg,aatniodn, to vaoriuoruN s oot.h1ercpom rop- any mfoor rdeivdeirvseirtsyeacruelgtuorien,gbtuot bweernade- ed
publisbhenocnhems caraklliinnggpuros d“usicntneexrasm.”ine besthipbriatcivtiecelsa.ws and praiccatilclyesd. ifferent from taocroemmpeamnbyewr iatnhdabveeshtoignia eslt about
What Hcroiwtercioamdpoan thieesyguau seg?e the effectivenessWofetnheeeird to be redmivinerdseit
dy-tmhaatnagemenwtheyffowret.needed diversity in the first
own practices is by having benchmaArkfsr.ic TahneAbmesetricans are tUhelti omnlaytely, Monsptlearc’s e.a Ypopuromacahy i nnodtibcaete as blae ltaockreap
Phil Rbyeannchmarks are from companies thamt ainreoraicttyua glrobuespt, otheorf tuhnadnetrhsteanding ofththee“bbe en neeffiittss”oofragedtivtehresi“trye-cogni-
Kingstpoenrf,oNrm. Ye.rs, not companies with theNlaartgievset Apumbelirci-cans, wmha erneag weimdee-nt progratmio.n T” hliekeretshueltasffoefctdeidvegrrsoituyps, but
relations budget or highest name-braspnrdearedcolagwnsiti woenr.e pasmseadniangestmateent are meyaosu urcaabnlebaenpdarctoonftrtihbeustoeld utirioec nt.-
We agree that “representation shaoftuelrdstnaotet,bwehich prolyhitboittehdetchoerporate bottAorme wliene rea qnudireedqutoityadvdarleuses the
RacismtheStoilnl lay FmaecatsoufreLmifeent that a compfarneeyduosmess.”in every asfpoerctshoafrleihfeotld he atrs. needs, concerns, because of their
I al Twhaayts’sfwinhdyywoeurloaorkticfalerspast “represwenastaetniojn o”yeads bay other AUmseirnigcatnoso.lIstthat frualcfiel,l omfetdhiooscerewehxopehcatvaetionnost i bseaen
extremmeelytritch.o Tuhgehtf-opurroa vroekaisn Tg.heI DiversitwyaIn s cby Tolapw5t0hat AfricgaonodAw maeyrit
coanssoft-pedtahleyvoiuctrimdisveorfsitthyeetfyfopretso.fItdimscary
imi-also nCotoemd p…ani aescofomrmDeinvetrrsi etgya®rds-urvey mweearseukreespa t roeut and lapwlasclaiktee mthaenagementnin atiloesns tphraotghreasssisvheapcoedmp thainsiceos,untry?
ing thCe EetOhnCicoimtymoiftmCDenOt, sH(uAmskan CapitCali,viCl oRripgohrtastAe ct of 1b8u7t1i,t’s18n7o5w, ay to be competitive.
the WChiotme Gmuuyni–caDtiiovnesrsaitnydInScu.cpopmlie).r Div1e9r6si4ty,.1T9h9e1, the Voting Rights Act, Pamela Alfred-George
I woudldatlaikweetocoollfefcetr ianpth oianttcofomrpetitionanisdthoethbearssislafwors sinceLuthkeenV, iwsceo renti
considoeurratbioenncthhmatarnkoinognseersveiecme.sWe inclduedseigbneesdt ptoraicn-clude Fthoeumlis. IPreeaaclloyck CONTACT US…
[to] ratiisceesaa snwdesfuogrggeestaehdenadexitnsttehpes in ouwroduelldivleirkaebeleveryone, like the gentle- We welcome your comments. Letters continued quest for equality and man who questionedPatr hten[eerxscalunsdioCno]foundmeurst include your name, address reports and in-person
debriefs.th e achievement of equality of white CDOs, to rpeucobglinsh izeer@thDativersityIn ancd.c,oifmapplicable, company affiliation The quality of the benchmarking product is and title. Send letters via e-mail to
througrehladtiivveertsoithy.ow data is collected. Wthhaeteqffuoersttsiomnasde to include minori-
editor@DiversityInc.com. We reserve
the right to edit all submissions.